Substitution and Commodification in Pynchon's Against the Day

 

Just beginning the mammoth endeavor of re-reading Pynchon’s Against the Day (2006). My first run through, which took three months, was in 2010.  One hundred or so pages in, I’m reminded yet again how much fun he is to read. In the first place, I would argue that he is a generally underrated prose stylist. Dude can flat out write! Secondly, of course, are his bizarre and labyrinthine plots coupled to a Dickensian profusion of eccentric characters with memorable and allusive names. But for me, there’s another pleasure too …

His novels are also encyclopedic treasure chests of forgotten customs, obscure historical detail, cultural ephemera and scientific oddities. In short, when reading Pynchon, you never know what you might learn along the way.

Take, for example, something I probably should have learned in, say, 11th grade … but didn’t. (Or if I did, I had forgotten).

During the American Civil War, both Union and Confederate armies permitted men to hire “substitutes” to serve in their place. Under the Union’s Enrollment Act, for example, a conscripted man could provide a substitute or pay what was referred to as a “commutation fee” of $300. The Confederacy also permitted substitution but, there, the policy was abolished in 1863.

The entire system was, as you might imagine, controversial. It allowed rich folk to avoid the dangers of military service while someone else, usually someone with little means, took their place. This practice only served to reinforce the perception (reality?) that this was a rich man’s conflict in which the poor did all the fighting.


Cut back to Against the Day and enter the wealthy industrialist, Scarsdale Vibe (great name, no!), and his substitute, Foley Walker (another allusive name, though not so obvious). The arrangement between the two is much more than merely an interesting historical footnote. What it does, in fact, is establish in microcosm – and very early on – the relationship between wealth and power that thereafter wends its way throughout the novel. Because of his enormous means, Vibe can easily purchase an escape from a devastating national catastrophe. He transfers, that is to say, his personal obligation to another human being. Walker is, in effect, the vehicle – or better, instrument – through which Vibe’s privilege is manifest and exercised.

The word “substitute” is, I think, significant in the novel beyond its military context. Against the Day is full of characters who adopt alternative identities, assume disguises, and find themselves enmeshed in systems whose machinations and aims are frequently invisible to them. Because of this, the distinction between the original and its “substitute” – between the person who acts and the person or persons who benefit – becomes increasingly difficult to determine. Who’s really doing the work, in other words, and who’s getting the credit? Maybe more to our point, who’s paying the price?

Pynchon seldom does anything simply for the sake of doing it. Even his most exuberant narrative excesses are far from gratuitous. They all, ultimately, fulfill a thematic purpose. And that holds true with regard to his fondness for seemingly random historical curiosities. The system of Civil War substitution offers a great example of how institutions and bureaucracies can morph human obligations into commodities. As anyone even minimally familiar with his work knows, such commodification is a Pynchonian preoccupation.  

More to come as I progress further and further into the text …


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Honolulu Noir (Eddie O'Brien, PI)

The Last Pitch

Trouble in Paradise: The Problem of Violence in Stanislaw Lem's, Eden (1958)